News/ Updates
DVD Reviews
DVD Reviews 2016
Blu-ray Reviews
Blu-ray Reviews 2016
Blu-ray Reviews 2017
Movie Reviews
Movie Reviews 2016
Movie Reviews 2017
Movie review: ALIEN: COVENANT
Blu-ray review: LOGAN
Blu-ray review: THE SPACE BETWEEN US
Blu-ray review: THE GREAT WALL
DVD Review: DEATH RACE 2050


movie review by David Blackwell


122 minutes, Rated R

STUDIO: 20th Century Fox/ TSG Entertainment/ Scott Free Productions

Theatrical RELEASE DATE: 5-19-2017 (USA/ Canada)

It has been ten years since the Prometheus expedition met their fate.   The colony ship Covenant picks up a human transmission from an unknown Earth type planet.   They journey to the world mostly dead of animal life and encounter the android David (Michael Fassbender) after finding a crashed Engineer spaceship.  They will learn about the fate of Elizabeth Shaw’s quest to go to the Engineer homeworld while facing a new biological menace and making sure they don’t bring any unknown danger to the sleeping colonists they’re transporting in the Covenant.  Can they trust David and what has David been doing on the unknown planet all this time?


I have been a big fan of the first ALIEN movies and enjoyed the flawed PROMETHEUS.  ALIEN RESURRECTION has its flaws and ALIENS VS PREDATOR movies are much hit and miss.   Now Ridley Scott has come up with a follow up to PROMETHEUS called ALIEN: COVENANT which captures some of the atmosphere of the original ALIEN only to be a frustrating sequel to PROMETHEUS (more than PROMETHEUS could ever be disappointing).   PROMETHEUS found a way to expand the ALIEN universe mythology where ALIEN: COVENANT unfortunately goes in the direction of retconning the mythology in unsatisfying ways.   The first hour of the movie has a great set-up, but the second half just sees plot logic go out the window as android David is revealed as the true bad guy of the movie.  I would have loved to have seen more of Elizabeth Shaw in this movie besides the two minute prequel short and pictures of her.  Her fate is revealed after the fact because I would have loved to see her face the Engineers before she faced whatever fate she faces.   


One of the biggest problems with the newest prequel is the characters are underdeveloped.  I was watching parts of PROMETHEUS on FX recently after seeing ALIEN: COVENANT and I saw how the characters were much more developed than any of the characters of ALIEN: COVENANT (but it doesn’t hurt you have such great actors as Charlize Theron, Idris Elba, Guy Pearce, Noomi Rapace, and Michael Fasbender all together in one movie).   I don’t really care for any of the characters as much as I did for many of the characters of PROMETHEUS.  Android David (Michael Fasbender) quotes Shelley and Byron while having a taste for the music of Wagner.  His interactions with android Walter (also played by Fassbender) are one of the highlights of the new prequel.  Lots of character development was left on the cutting room floor as Ridley Scott is trying to focus more on pacing than delivering the best movie (and this was the same issue I had with PROMETHEUS- look at the deleted scenes and imagine how some of the movie’s holes would be plugged if many of those scenes were left in).   One scene introducing the crew of the Covenant is on Youtube (and it will probably be on the blu-ray) was cut from the movie and it would have gone a long way in making you care for the crew more.  The other thing I’m wondering is how much material between Shaw and David was shot.  There are also scenes cut from the third act of the movie too.   My biggest piece of advice for Ridley Scott is  find better balance plot and character development with pacing since I found PROMETHEUS to be a more satisfying prequel than ALIEN: COVENANT (sometimes you have to follow your gut on telling the best story without trying to guess what the audiences or studio wants).


This review is 5-23-2017 David Blackwell and cannot be reprinted without permission.  Send all comments to feedback@enterline-media.com


Like Enterline Media on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/enterlinemediaweb and follow on tumblr at http://enterlinemedia.tumblr.com